Venkaiah Naidu rejects opposition's impeachment motion against CJI

24 April, 2018, 05:11 | Author: Edward Snyder
  • India Dipak Misra

Eminent jurists like Soli Sorabjee and Fali Nariman and some ex-judges did not find fault with today's decision of Rajya Sabha Chairman M Venkaiah Naidu rejecting the impeachment notice against Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra but there was a political divide among lawyers associated with various parties on the outcome.

Informed sources said that Naidu was not happy with the way the opposition parties had straightway gone to the media after submitting their impeachment motion to him. Sibal said the Congress will move a petition in the Supreme Court challenging this order. "And that's why we have left it to his (CJI) conscience", he added, reports IANS.

"What was the tearing hurry?" But if there was even the slightest suspicion, it became the duty of Parliament to take note of that, he said.

"Obviously there was some tearing hurry. I don't think momentous matters such as these should be dealt with in such a hurried fashion".

"It is our privilege to move the motion".

The Congress, which led the opposition bid to impeach the Chief Justice, had however said that it will move the Supreme Court if the Vice President rejected the impeachment motion. But Congress allegations of less than fair play must be set against the motion's merit or lack of it. "I have applied my mind to all five charges made out in impeachment motion and examined all annexed documents".




The order destroys the legitimate processes of the law. He said that the party is going to accept whatever decision the court takes. "This will jeopardise the judicial system", he concluded.

"Naidu cited a Supreme Court order to reiterate that the CJI, as Master of Roster, was entitled to allocate cases as he deemed fit and referred it as an internal matter of the judiciary". "So, this is likely to be rejected", the Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs said.

"No conspiracy can be proved by direct evidence". It sinks the bar for a measure that requires utmost circumspection, maximum consensus and unimpeachable evidence.

Justice Dhingra, too, supported Naidu's order on impeachment and said, "Rejection was absolutely right and based on facts". "How do you verify something without an inquiry". This is a very serious matter and we can't allow the cancer of corruption to grow. Maybe they have information that the CBI has information, maybe by scuttling the inquiry they don't want a lot of information to come on record.

In a separate tweet, Surjewala wrote, "Within hours of 64 MP's submitting the impeachment motion, Leader of Rajya Sabha (FM) had expressed naked prejudice by calling it a "revenge petition" virtually dictating the verdict to Rajya Sabha Chairman on that day. I will not get into the reasons (which everybody knows), but I will say that this is a part of a larger trend to demonise and weaken every institution that seeks to maintain its individual identity and not kowtow to the dynasty", Shah said in a blog.

Recommended:



Popular

Andrew Landry wins the Texas open by two shots
Mullinax, 25, swung away in the final threesome on Sunday in the fourth round of the Valero Texas Open, chasing his first PGA Tour win.

In Iran-Israel Tension, Netanyahu Warns of 'Heavy Price'
The Prime minister addressed that it is 2018 and Iran openly speaks about liquidating Israel. However, he noted that the policy of controlling "flames" contains a large amount of risk.

Senate committee may oppose Mike Pompeo as U.S. secretary of state
Still, some observers predict a historic setback for the president in the Foreign Relations Committee vote. All Democrats on the committee are expected to vote against Pompeo, 54.

Taleban attacks kill 14 troops, policemen in Afghanistan
Tolo news further reports that by Sunday mid-day, there had been five attacks in less than a week against the election process. Health officials said the family had been driving past the voter registration centre when the explosives were detonated.

OnePlus 6 to arrive with new materials, with same craftsmanship
OnePlus 6 official launch is expected in a few days, and everyday something new about the device emerges on the internet. And this collaboration with Marvel Studios is for the OnePlus 6 smartphone , which is going to be launched very soon.

Saudi Arabia says intercepted Houthi missiles launched at Aramco facility
The coalition said another missile crashed in a Saudi desert on Sunday, without specifying a location, adding it caused no damage. On October 7, 2015, another air raid killed 43 people at a wedding in Sanaban village in the Dhammar governorate in Yemen .

Minnesota Timberwolves: 3 takeaways from Game 3 vs. Rockets
Butler stayed in the game, but he did look a step slow to start the third quarter before really heating up later. That, along with a resurgence from Karl-Anthony Towns, helped Minnesota get a win and get back in the series.

Gregg Popovich will reportedly miss second consecutive game
San Antonio faces a big uphill battle, as no National Basketball Association team has overcome a 3-0 series deficit. Superstar LeBron James [VIDEO ], who is very fond of the #Hall of Fame coach , said on TNT , "I'm a huge Pop fan".

Update on Humboldt Broncos bus crash investigation expected today
Zablocki said the driver's logs have been seized by police, though it's unclear whether the logs are on paper or digital. As of the latest update provided by the team Tuesday, nine people remain hospitalized, with two in critical condition.

USA watchdog refers report on Andrew McCabe to prosecutors
In 2015, while McCabe was head of the FBI's Washington Field Office, his wife ran for state senate in Virginia as a Democrat. I like him very much as a person but sometimes even good people do things they shouldn't do", he said. "Potentially.