Supreme Court collegium reiterates Justice KM Joseph's name for elevation

14 May, 2018, 00:14 | Author: Edward Snyder
  • Supreme Court file

DESPITE objections from the Centre, the Supreme Court Collegium on Friday stood by its recommendation to elevate Uttarakhand Chief Justice Justice K M Joseph as judge of the apex court.

In its meeting today, it "unanimously agreed" that that the recommendation for appointment of Justice KM Joseph as a Judge of the Supreme Court "should be reiterated".

Justice Jasti Chelameswar, the second-most senior judge in the Supreme Court, had written a letter to the CJI on Thursday, seeking the reiteration of Justice Joseph's name for elevation.

With the collegium likely to assert its authority in appointment of Judges to the Supreme Court, this is expected to result in a major confrontation with the Centre, which has expressed its reservations on Justice Joseph's appointment to the top court. There are some indications that separate files could be sent - one for Justice K M Joseph's name and the other for more judges.

On 2 May, when the collegium met to discuss the matter, it had to defer its decision due to a "lack of unanimity".




"While Justice Joseph's nomination had been cleared by the collegium on January 11, the others are yet to be approved - so they are on a different footing", a source said. It also added that there was an adequate representation of Kerala in the higher judiciary from where he hails.

Apart from Joseph, the other names that the collegium considered were Indira Banerjee, now chief justice of the Madras HC, who is originally from the Calcutta HC; Gujarat HC chief justice R. Subhash Reddy, who is originally from the Telangana and Andhra Pradesh HC; and Karnataka HC chief justice Dinesh Maheshwari, who is originally from the Rajasthan HC.

According to an apex court official, Justice Chelameswar, in his letter sent to the CJI, had conveyed that he was reiterating his decision favaouring elevation of Justice Joseph as the judge of the top court as there was no change in the circumstances that had led the Collegium to recommend his name to the government on January 10. Further, the Centre urged to give representation to several High Courts who did not have a fair representation in the Supreme Court.

While asking for reconsideration, the Centre argued that Justice Joseph was way too junior in the all-India seniority list of judges and that his parent HC, Kerala, was adequately represented through Justice Kurian Joseph.

The Supreme Court Collegium meeting of Friday (May 11) threw up a solution of sorts, nearly exactly as India Legal had predicted.

Recommended:

  • No Ebola in Kenya, Government Says

    No Ebola in Kenya, Government Says

    This Ebola outbreak is the DRC's 9th known outbreak since 1976, reports the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Ebola is spread through person-to-person contact with the blood, or other bodily fluids, of an infected person.
    Apple plans Amazon-style distribution strategy

    Apple plans Amazon-style distribution strategy

    Netflix and YouTube, owned by rival Alphabet Inc., operate the two largest online video services in the world outside of China. If Apple were to push through with its plan, the TV app will become the ultimate hub for users to find and stream content.
    California first U.S.  state to require solar on new homes

    California first U.S. state to require solar on new homes

    They estimate that for every $40 in monthly payments the energy standards increase, consumers will save $80 in energy costs . In the long-term, building more homes - soon with solar panels - could drive down living costs in the Golden State .
  • Cuomo appoints special prosecutor to investigate Schneiderman

    Cuomo appoints special prosecutor to investigate Schneiderman

    Mr Schneiderman became attorney general in 2010 and had meant to run for re-election to the post this year. They sought medical attention after the assaults, but none reported the incidents to the police.
    Trump lauds capture of five top ISIS commanders

    Trump lauds capture of five top ISIS commanders

    The Iraqi air force has carried out several air strikes since past year against Islamic State positions in Syrian territory. Dillon's tweet said the capture was a coordinated operation between Iraqi and the USA backed Syrian Democratic Forces.
    Manchester City smash Premier League points record

    Manchester City smash Premier League points record

    Records tumbled as City took their goals tally for the campaign to 105, their points total to 97 and their number of wins to 31. David Silva and Raheem Sterling are also in double figures meaning they are the first team ever with four players at that mark.
  • Tottenham Hotspur 1-0 Newcastle United

    Tottenham Hotspur 1-0 Newcastle United

    They have played this season at Wembley Stadium. "As I said, it's been tough but I'm delighted we've finished it off well". Spurs have one more game at Wembley on Sunday when they face Leicester before returning to the Lane next season.
    Mitch McConnell boasts about Don Blankenship's loss in West Virginia GOP primary

    Mitch McConnell boasts about Don Blankenship's loss in West Virginia GOP primary

    Republicans are more positive toward Ryan (67% favorable) than Democrats are toward Pelosi (57% see her favorably). In the latest CNN poll, Democrats are leading on the generic congressional ballot by only 3 percentage points.
    Celtics players wanted Joel Embiid to 'man up' after all trash talking

    Celtics players wanted Joel Embiid to 'man up' after all trash talking

    The Boston Celtics had physically and mentally messed with the 21-year-old Australian basketball prodigy over five games. The Eastern Conference Finals start Sunday and the Western Conference Finals start Monday.
  • Oil Rockets to 2014 Highs as Trump Quits Iran Deal

    Oil Rockets to 2014 Highs as Trump Quits Iran Deal

    Israel said it conducted the biggest raid in at least three decades at Iran's military facilities inside Syria. Trump's decision to pull out of the Iran deal has left his country diplomatically isolated.
    United States  drone program taps Apple, passes over Amazon, China's DJI

    United States drone program taps Apple, passes over Amazon, China's DJI

    Uber is working with San Diego, which wants to create drone landing stations and ports, according to a fact sheet released by DOT. It will partner with outdoor research facility Green Valley Farms Living Laboratory, CNN, and AirMap .
    Buffett bashes bitcoin, gushes over Apple

    Buffett bashes bitcoin, gushes over Apple

    For a day, the value of "digital gold " fell by 9% after a sharp statement by the head of Microsoft on CNBC to bitcoin . Shorting is a method of trade where you bet against the market going down and make profits on the inverse of trends.


Popular

PM Offers Prayers At Iconic Muktinath Temple
On Saturday morning PM prayed at Muktinath temple and tried out the traditional drums along with the temple priests. It has been further reported that there will be a number of routes to be launched between India and Nepal .

SpaceX To Launch First "Block 5" Falcon 9 Rocket Thursday
Block 5 is the first iteration of the booster that is meant to be used in 10 launches with only minor refurbishing between uses. The "block 5" version of the craft features a number of design changes the company claims will improve performance and safety.

Thanos Lands in Fortnite, Gets Nerfed Immediately
It was a clever crossover that directors Joe and Anthony Russo began considering during the editing phase of Infinity War . Earlier this week, Epic Games introduced the limited-time Fortnite Thanos mode, complete with the Infinity Gaunlet.

Flyers prospect Lyon makes 94 saves in longest game in AHL history
Lyon was the Frank Brimsek victor as the top high school goalie in the state in 2011 and was a three-year standout at Yale. That's 94 stops on 95 shots, or a.989 save percentage through almost eight periods of hockey.

Peyton Manning wanted by Panthers bidder in ownership group
Carolina ranks 21st among the NFL's 32 franchises, with a $2.3 billion valuation, according to the most recent calculations from Forbes .

You Can Now Buy Movie Tickets With Google Assistant
Tell your device "I'm Home " and it'll turn on the lights, set the temperature, turn on your TV, or even start a music playlist. The dinner reservation was extremely impressive , as the Assistant had to understand someone with a strong accent.

At least 21 people killed as Kenyan dam bursts following heavy rains
According to Kibicho, the government had so far distributed food and medicine worth Sh600 million in thirty-two affected counties. Its walls are said to have caved in due to the high volumes of water following heavy rains that have been pounding the country.

Rory McIlroy has a hate-love relationship with The Players
Starting on the 12th hole of the first round, he went birdie-bogey-bogey-bogey-eagle-birdie-bogey to cap off a 73. I've been rolling it well, I just haven't been making any putts. "So if I want to keep it, I have to play well".

Ridgefield High School Ranked #5 In Connecticut
Barstow High School and Academy of Careers and Exploration in Helendale each earned a bronze level, despite not being ranked. Suncoast High School has once again earned a spot on a "Top 100" list for national literacy achievements.

Indian fraudsters ridiculed after being paraded in 'space suits'
According to the police, the victim later found out that the "scientist" was working with the accused, and was being paid ₹20,000. Once the complaint was lodged, the police arrested the Brar duo who deals in antique/rare metals.